Tuesday, 24 April 2018

NFL Mock Draft 2018

Colin Bell's Mock Draft 2018


Time again for the annual mock draft ahead of the 2018 NFL Draft. It's the quarterbacks that are taking most of the headlines in the run up to the draft. The early successes of Carson Wentz, Jared Goff and DeShaun Watson have added pressure to QB needy teams to move up the board to ensure they have an opportunity to land the next big prospect but it's an intriguing juxtaposition with a QB class that could easily see 5 passers selected in the first round balanced against no clear standout QB in the class and both talent and enough questions on each potential first round passer to make it a risky selection.

Arguably the highest ranked players in this class in terms of pro grades are at the less fashionable, lower draft valued positions. It sets up a fascinating first night of the draft. We're likely to see over-drafting at the QB position, but for teams with a need at QB it's going to potentially result in some of the very best of this class falling into the middle of the first round. 

In terms of my mock, it's straight forward rules as ever - no trades projected unless confirmed prior to draft, once off the board a player can't be projected as a pick to another team. 

With that said, let's get it started....


1. Cleveland Browns - QB Sam Darnold (USC)

Wentz, Goff, Trubisky, Watson, Mahomes.... just a list of some of the QB's the Browns have passed on in the first round in the last two years. The Browns have two first round picks in 2018 and a further three in the second round. Let's give some credit to deposed GM Sashi Brown for assembling a host of draft picks that should benefit the new GM John Dorsey and significantly upgrade the roster from the 2018 class.

The Browns are slated to pick at #1 and #4 in the first round which gives them an incredibly strong position at the top of the draft. With Tyrod Taylor on board you could argue the Browns could be tempted to take Saquon Barkley here but the pressure on the Browns to find their own Wentz at the top of this draft will probably be too great. Not only have they passed on some upcoming stars in the previous few drafts, Taylor is in the final season of his contract the Browns picked up from Buffalo. With the Giants and Jets positioned at #2 and #3 respectively, they could both feasibly select a QB and leave Cleveland with their third preference rookie passer when they come to pick again at #4

The betting money seems to be on the Browns picking USC QB Sam Darnold here. Darnold's 2017 campaign wasn't as strong as 2016 but neither was his supporting cast. Darnold is a prototype size QB and on-field leader with experience in a pro-style offense. However, his tool set needs work, he's certainly not the NFL ready QB that some people have portrayed him as - yet. But with Tyrod Taylor the likely starting QB come week 1, Darnold can be allowed to develop at his own rate and the Browns can work on his suspect release and his propensity to hold the ball in one hand when under pressure (9 lost fumbles in 2017).

Pick Fact : This is the 7th occasion a team has picked overall #1 in consecutive years since the collegiate draft began in 1936. Oh, and the last time? It was Cleveland again back in 1999/2000 (Tim Couch and Courtney Brown were the picks)

2. New York Giants - QB Josh Rosen (UCLA)

How much longer for Eli Manning? My eyes tell me not long but it's a hard thing to draw closure on a two-time super bowl winner behind centre. Do the Giants regard themselves as a win now team in Eli's twilight or a team in transition with new GM and Head Coach who have the luxury of a rebuild process and sitting a rookie passer to learn from a veteran in his 15th year?

It seems that the Giants have confidence Eli will see out the remaining two years of his contract. It remains to be seen if the new Front Office have the same confidence as the previous incumbents in 2017 3rd round pick Davis Webb as understudy and future starter or use this unique position to draft their QB of the future. 

My own take is that I think this pick is highly tradeable. I could see the Broncos making a move from #5 if they had a strong interest in someone. I also think that Dave Gettleman's former disciple Brandon Beane in Buffalo owns two first rounders and a QB need. To this end I'm surprised the Jets didn't make a strong play for the #2 pick to avoid being leapfrogged in their QB search. Maybe the Jets are confident in the direction the Giants are going. I'm not.

Dave Gettleman doesn't have a history of trading down, and the #2 pick offers the Giants a broad selection to take Eli's eventual successor. If, the Front Office decide to address the immediate needs instead this would maybe see the Giants select RB Saquon Barkley who I think is the best prospect in the entire class. This would be a team need and a BPA decision. The Giants could also look to grab an edge rusher such as Bradley Chubb to replace traded Jason Pierre Paul or the best O-lineman Quenton Nelson to pair with recently signed ex-Pat Nate Solder. However, it's not often the Giants pick this soon and with Eli in his twilight it would make sense to capitalise here. Josh Rosen has all the tools and an aloofness that is reminiscent of Manning.

Pick Fact : The last time the Giants selected this high in the draft was back in 1984 when they selected Hall-of-Fame linebacker Lawrence Taylor second overall. Not a bad pick. Coincidentally, their last pick in the top 5 was in 2004 when they picked Phillip Rivers by default and engineered the trade for Eli Manning.


3. New York Jets - QB Josh Allen (Wyoming)

The Jets gave up some of the house to get up to #3, so it can really only mean one thing, a new QB in said house. I don't think this QB class has an absolute certainty in it, but one thing I do like is that each rookie QB wouldn't be expected to start day one. There are decent bridge options on each of the Browns, Giants and Jets rosters. It's unfortunate for the Jets they're not going to be able to pick carte blanche. They're likely selecting the third passer in the draft and claiming he was their guy all along.


I'm not sure of the Jets grading but assuming Darnold and Rosen are gone, then it's most likely the strongest armed QB (Allen) that gets picked here although the most confident (Mayfield) may bring some New York swagger. I think I'd personally go for Mayfield but the stronger arm and taller physique probably tend towards the pick being Josh Allen.

Pick Fact : Should 3 QB's be selected with the first 3 picks it will be a scenario reminiscent of the 2015 draft class where the first 3 picks were all passers (Jameis Winston, Marcus Mariota and Blake Bortles). This is a rare event only occuring previously in 1999 (Tim Couch, Donovan McNabb and Akili Smith) and 1971 (Jim Plunkett, Archie Manning and Dan Pastorini)

4. Cleveland Browns - RB Saquon Barkley (Penn State)

If the draft stacks this way the Browns have got to be delighted. They'll have chosen their QB of the future and effectively own the #2 pick of the draft too from their needs perspective. The options here are plentiful but I'd limit them to two choices, Bradley Chubb or Saquon Barkley.

Bradley Chubb would make a very viable selection on the edge potentially combining with last years overall #1 Myles Garrett to create a formidable tandem. However, I'd personally hand the card in with Saquon Barkley's name in bold if he's still here.

There's a lot of RB depth in this draft and the Browns have signed Carlos Hyde in free agency and Duke Johnson is an ascending star so this pick is by no means a certainty. The trend to value backs lower in the draft these days is accepted, but Barkley could be a transcendental back and provide instant upgrade to the Browns offense. It's a pass led-league but recent top 10 picks Todd Gurley, Ezekiel Elliott and last years #4 pick Leonard Fournette prove there's life in the position still.

Barkley rushed for over 1000 yards in each of his 3 seasons at Penn State, amassing 18 rushing TD's in each of his last 2 seasons. He's also a decent receiver adding 632 receiving yards in his final year with the Nittany Lions, not forgetting 2 kick returns for scores and a passing TD.

Comparisons with Marshall Faulk, LaDainiain Tomlinson and Barry Sanders may flatter Barkley or simply give him a target to aim for. I think he's the safest pick in this years draft.

Pick Fact :  Buyer beware. The last time the Browns selected a RB this high they were burnt by RB Trent Richardson, picked overall #3 and out of the league within 3 years. Indeed they've only picked a RB 4 times in the 1st round in the last 36 years and none of the players selected reached 3000 career rushing yards (although Eric Metcalf did eventually convert to WR and have over 5000 career receiving yards, but even then only half of these yards were with Cleveland);


5. Denver Broncos -  OG Quenton Nelson (Notre Dame)

Don't rule out the Broncos interest in a QB. I'd be intrigued to hear GM John Elway's assessment on Oklahoma's Baker Mayfield and could easily see Denver pull the trigger on a new Quarterback.


However, the biggest glaring need on their offense is an interior lineman and whilst Guard isn't a fashionable pick, Quenton Nelson is a beast and easily the best offensive lineman in this class. A superior run blocker, he could slot into left guard and form a solid left side of the Broncos line for the next decade with Garrett Bolles, last years 1st rounder.

It's not the most fashionable pick but maybe John Elway as a former QB is all too aware of the importance of protection in the pocket. 



Pick Fact : In the previous 26 years the Broncos have only selected in the first 10 picks once (Von Miller selected #2 overall in 2011).


6. Indianapolis Colts -  DE Bradley Chubb (North Carolina St.)

Despite cap room the Colts fanbase were frustrated at the Front Office inactivity during free agency but the focus is on a rebuild via the draft. The switch of picks with the Jets has given the Colts 4 of the top 50 picks to re-stock the roster.

I think it's a best player available strategy here and Denver's pick at #5 will largely determine the Colts strategy. If Quenton Nelson is available I'd probably offer Andrew Luck an offensive line upgrade but Chubb is likely the best pass rusher in the class and is decent against the run too and to top it all off has experience in coverage also. Having posted two back-to-back 10 sack seasons at NC State he should be ready to start immediately in Indy.

Whilst Tremaine Edmunds or Roquan Smith would be huge upgrades at linebacker, greater value is placed on linemen so it would make immense sense for GM Chris Ballard to make Chubb the first of his 4 picks in the top 50.

Pick Fact : The last DE selected out of North Carolina State in the first round was Mario Williams back in 2006 who posted 97.5 career sacks in a career with Houston, Buffalo and Miami. During the 2016 and 2017 seasons Chubb also wore the same #9 jersey that Williams did in his college career.


7. Tampa Bay Buccs -  DB Derwin James (Florida State)

253. That's the number of receiving yards Julio Jones torched the Tampa secondary for in week 12 last year. That's got to be on the Front Office minds.

The trades for Vinny Curry and Jason Pierre Paul has the Buccs addressing their all too obvious pass rush problem, so maybe Bradley Chubb would be out of play here now regardless. I think a versatile 6'3 defensive back could be just the tonic. Derwin
James can play corner, is probably best suited as a box safety but will provide undoubted leadership, size and athleticism in the secondary. These traits are vitally needed in the NFC South.

Pick Fact : Only one Hall-of-Famer has ever been selected at #7 in the collegiate draft. LB/C Clyde "Bulldog" Turner was selected by the Chicago Bears back in 1940.


8. Chicago Bears -  LB Tremaine Edmunds (Virginia Tech)

The Bears have actively pursued skill position talent (Allen Robinson, Taylor Gabriel and Trey Burton) on offense for new HC Matt Nagy and second year QB Mitch Trubisky in free agency.

Now I think it's time to turn to the defense with the intriguing prospect Tremaine Edmunds a hot pick for Chicago. Edmunds has an intriguing size (6'5) and speed mix (4.54 combine 40) and translated this into 215 tackles (32.5 for loss) and 10 sacks in his last 2 seasons in college. The physical tool set and potential is immense with Edmunds, with comparisons to Brian Urlacher already referenced. The downside is that he's not the most instinctive linebacker and his play diagnosis and instincts will need to develop. This could mean the Bears play it safer with Roquan Smith an alternative option but the Bears have not been shy of drafting athletic freaks as recently as Leonard Floyd (#9 in 2016) and Edmunds could offer massive upside - definitely a classic boom-bust pick

Pick Fact : Tremaine Edmunds is the son of two-time Pro Bowl TE and former Miami Dolphins / Seattle Seahawk Ferrell Edmunds.


9. San Francisco 49ers - LB Roquan Smith (Georgia)

The 49ers are probably looking for help on both sides of the trenches but also conscious of providing Jimmy Garropolo with a #1 receiver to go alongside his new 5-yr $137.5m contract.

I originally marked Alabama's Calvin Ridley as the likely receiving option but then the 49ers 2017 1st round pick LB Reuben Foster gets indicted on 3 felony charges including a domestic violence charge which has left GM John Lynch stating that if the charge is proven Foster will no longer be part of the organisation.

With this in mind I've amended my mock to send out a clear message to Foster.

Georgia's Roquan Smith is a prototypical modern linebacker. The pro comparison with the Falcons Deion Jones is a fair one, a little undersized with great speed, superior play diagnosis and explosive athleticism. Smith was a high school WR and exhibits that knowledge when in pass coverage, easily able to match even the most athletic RB's and he's not afraid to bring it in the run game either.

Pick Fact : Should the 49ers actually select a WR in the first round they'll be hoping for more than the one season they got out of their 2012 pick A.J Jenkins. After a catchless rookie year he was traded to the Chiefs and after 17 catches in the next 2 seasons was out of football.


10. Oakland Raiders - DB Minkah Fitzpatrick (Alabama)

This is Jon Gruden's first draft pick in a long, long time so all eyes on Chucky here at #10. Nearly every mock draft I see has the Raiders taking Roquan Smith and not without good reason. However, I have the 49ers jumping the Raiders for Smith, so their focus can shift to their secondary which is in dire need of playmakers.

My mock still has the best coverage defensive backs on the board. I could see the Raiders looking at Minkah Fitzpatrick, Denzel Ward or Josh Jackson as alternatives to Smith. Similarly, outside of Khalil Mack there isn't much of a pass rush to write home about so we could also see an edge guy get the nod but beyond Bradley Chubb I'm unsure if any other edge guy will go in the top 20 this year.

I've seen Minkah Fitzpatrick linked as high as #4 to the Browns and he's been compared with Jamal Adams who went #6 to the 49ers last year. Fitzpatrick played as a freshman for Alabama and not many do that in the Tide's strong football programme. He has proven he can excel in man or zone coverage and has shown effectiveness as a blitzer and brings great ball skills (also returning 4 of his 9 college interceptions for TD's). He's perhaps more likely to play safety in the NFL but could easily flex to corner. Some scouts think he could be better than Jalen Ramsey who went #5 in 2016.

This is both a need and value pick for the Raiders and makes a lot of sense here at #10

Pick Fact : The Oakland Raiders have only selected 10th overall on one other occasion than 2018. It wasn't a bad selection either. The running back selected out of USC back in 1982 went on to become the only player to have won a Heisman Trophy, the NCAA Championship, the Super Bowl, Super Bowl MVP and NFL MVP. Marcus Allen was also inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame in 1999 and the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2003


11. Miami Dolphins - DT Vita Vea (Washington)



A popular move for the fanbase would be for the Dolphins to recruit Oklahoma QB Baker Mayfield if he should remain on the board past the Denver Broncos at #5. Ryan Tannehill is only 29 but coming off a surgically repaired ACL with not too much quality behind him holding a clipboard. I do like Mayfield but I'm not sure Adam Gase is ready to give up on Tannehill yet and think that the Dolphins may seek QB insurance lower down the draft.

There is also the calling for an impact player now to replace the departed Ndamukong Suh on the interior of the defensive line. The top interior linemen all remain on the board at this point so the Dolphins would have the pick of DaRon Payne, Vita Vea or Taven Bryan as most likely 1st rounder candidates to step into the rather large shoes of Suh. Vea nearly entered the draft last year but remained in college and saw his sack total dip slightly from 5 to 3.5. His ability as a big strong run defender won't be ignored but if picked at #11 the success of his selection will be dependent on Vea being more than just that big 340 pound run defender.

Pick Fact : Vea rushed for 587 yards and 11 TD's as a high school running back.


12. Buffalo Bills - QB Baker Mayfield (Oklahoma)

Is A.J McCarron the answer for the Bills? I assume they will double-down on another passer in the draft, the question is just how soon? A candidate to trade up for a QB, the Bills could just as easily move down from this spot to secure OL or WR help.

With my mock unable to project any movement I'm stuck at #12 so assume the Bills going QB (Baker Mayfield or Lamar Jackson) or looking for O-line help (Mike McGlinchey, Isaiah Wynn, Will Hernandez) or possibly even wide receiver with Calvin Ridley still on the board.

I think the Bills are going to be forced down the QB route here and it will be interesting to see how they go. I think I'm going to discount Lamar Jackson from the conversation on the basis of the Bills appearing to be more interested in a pocket passer than the ultra mobile Louisville QB.

Alongside Jackson, Baker Mayfield probably polarises opinion on his pro potential more than anyone else in this class. The first ever walk-on to win the Heisman Trophy, he improved his yardage and touchdown totals each year posting 4,267 yards 43 TD's and only 6 interceptions in his senior season.

He's an on-field leader with confidence that can border on cockiness which will need to be reigned in. Experts will point to his lack of ideal height and his stats padded via Oklahoma's spread offense, but he has a better arm than he's given credit for and his accuracy is reflected in a completion percentage in excess of 70% in his last two seasons in Oklahoma. His success could be dependent on scheme fit and coincidentally his pro comparison with a similarly vertically challenged passer Doug Flutie who happened to spend 3 years in Buffalo seems quite fitting.

Mayfield is one of the guys who absolutely fascinates me in this draft class. The Bills could have their QB and leader for the next decade or just the next undersized passer to struggle in the pros.

Pick Fact : When the Bills selected QB Joe Ferguson in 1973 (#57 overall) he started all 14 games posting 73 completions, an average of just over 5 per game. The 1973 season was the year O.J Simpson rumbled for 2,003 rushing yards, a then NFL record.


13. Washington Redskins - CB Denzel Ward (Ohio State)

I envisage the Skins focusing on defense in the early rounds of this years draft but do imagine the potential for a QB to be picked in the middle rounds - Kyle Lauletta anyone?

The Skins need a premier defender, be it a playmaking linebacker, help in the trenches or in the secondary. I think they'll take a BPA option and bearing in mind the departures of Kendall Fuller and Bashaud Breeland, it certainly wouldn't harm them to take a cornerback here at #13. Ward isn't the biggest physically at 5'10 and 185, but his superior footwork, athletic ability and overall speed make him arguably the top cover corner in the draft class. Due to his size he may be ideally suited to the slot and will potentially start his career as the nickel corner but don't be surprised to see him follow in the footsteps of two Ohio State alumni corners Marshon Lattimore and Gareon Conley, selected #11 and #24 respectively last year.

Pick Fact : Did you know that the Washington Redskins were the first team to ever draft a full-time kicker as a first round selection? The precedent was set by Charlie Gogolak, selected 6th overall out of Princeton in 1966 and only repeated twice since by Steve Little (#15 overall in 1978 by the St Louis Cardinals) and Sebastian Janikowski (#17 by the Oakland Raiders in 2000). Gogolak only lasted 3 years in Washington and 6 years in the league but part owns the record for most extra points converted in a single game by both teams. The other kicker? His brother Pete for the Giants.


14. Green Bay Packers - CB Josh Jackson (Iowa)

The Packers will likely have one eye on WR in the draft following the release of Jordy Nelson and a Randall Cobb contract which simply overpays based on his output. However, I feel there's enough value outside of the 1st round for the Pack to address this area and that they'll focus on improving their pass rush or pass defense early.

I've Harold Landry and Marcus Davenport as potential candidates as edge rushers but have opted for the equally obvious need at corner, where the Packers signed 35-yr old Tramon Williams as a stop-gap to pair with 2017 2nd rounder Kevin King and have the inconsistent Quentin Rollins as their nickel. Josh Jackson stands out after an amazing final year at Iowa culminating in 8 interceptions and 27 passes defensed. Some scouts have Jackson ranked as the best corner in the draft whereas others raise concern that he was only a one year starter for Iowa.

Pick Fact : The Packers have not drafted a skill player on offense in the first round since Aaron Rodgers in 2006. In the 11 years since, 9 selections have been defensive players with the only exceptions two offensive tackles in consecutive years in 2010 and 2011 (Bryan Bulaga and Derek Sherrod)


15. Arizona Cardinals - QB Lamar Jackson (Louisville)

I've swayed numerous times here between offensive tackle and quarterback, both as positions of need. I'm struggling to get past the number of times Sam Bradford has hit IR and my thinking is clouded with reports from his ex-HC Mike Zimmer on his degenerative knee condition. Despite Bradford being only 30 the injury toll probably means his signing is a shortish term manoeuvre. Mike Glennon was about to be the future of the Bears until the 2017 draft so maybe the Cards have a good fall back position or maybe Glennon really is a career backup.

With 4 QB's already off the board I think the Cardinals will react to the rush and look to Jackson even though there's plenty of logic in going lineman too. Jackson is raw as a passer but a dynamic athlete who has drawn some Mike Vick comparisons.

Jackson might not be the greatest passer at the moment and will miss occasionally on easy throws, but he brings a dynamism and level of excitement that's rarely seen at the QB position. The  Heisman Trophy winner in 2016 put up similar numbers again in 2017, which you can either look at as a concern that his passing numbers didn't improve or as a plus that he maintained his level despite a changing cast around him. Jackson passed for 57 TD's over his last 2 college seasons whilst also rushing for over 3,000 yards. His draft grade will vary massively between teams but the potential to be a difference maker could be huge.

Patience, the right system and remaining injury free will be critical to Jackson's success in the NFL. It almost seems a shame that it won't be the recently retired Bruce Arians with the job of developing an offense around Jackson whilst also helping refine his skills and decision making.


Pick Fact : If the Cardinals take Lamar Jackson or indeed any other QB in the first round, he will become only the second QB selected by the Cardinals in the 1st round since their move to Arizona. Within two years of their previous QB selection the Cardinals were in the Super Bowl. However, it wasn't with Matt Leinart as starter, he was already on the downside of his NFL career, backing up a resurgent Kurt Warner. 


16. Baltimore Ravens - WR Calvin Ridley (Alabama)

OK so I went with the fairytale first with Ravens GM Ozzie Newsome having pressing needs on the O-line following the departures of starting RT Austin Howard and C Ryan Jensen whilst the son of Newsome's late former team-mate Orlando Brown and namesake just happens to be available this year. Brown is a massive tackle at 6'8 and 345lbs and whilst his footwork won't win dancing competitions - to be honest it can be downright ugly at times - he's a large area to get around in pass protection and possesses extremely long arms and a strong punch. However a pretty terrible combine performance probably pushes Brown at least into Day Two.

Whilst there's a need on the O-line, and one that needs addressing, the Ravens also are short at WR. They're possibly acquiring Willie Snead pre-draft who has signed an offer sheet that New Orleans are unlikely to match, but this still only leaves him, 31-yr old Michael Crabtree on a 1-yr deal, John Brown and not much else behind them.

Enter Calvin Ridley who is possibly the drafts best WR, if not he's certainly the most polished. It's not a pass heavy offense at Alabama but Ridley still posted nearly 3,000 receiving yards during his 3-yr tenure. He'll likely follow in the footsteps of fellow Crimson Tide receivers Amari Cooper (#4 in 2015) and Julio Jones (#6 in 2011) as a first round pick and I have him as the first receiver off the board at #16. The knock on Ridley is that he's a little slight at 6'3 and 189lbs with a frame which is unlikely to add too much bulk. I still feel he's the best receiver on the board and better than what the Ravens currently have at their disposal.

Pick Fact : The Baltimore Ravens first two draft picks in franchise history are both in the Pro Football Hall-of-Fame. Ozzie Newsome, who retires after this season, selected Jonathan Ogden at #4 and followed this up with Ray Lewis at #26


17. Los Angeles Chargers - LB Rashaan Evans (Alabama)

Knowing HC Anthony Lynn covets mobile passers I wonder if the Chargers would be in the market for a QB if Lamar Jackson was still on the board. That said, Philip Rivers shows little sign of slowing down.

The immediate needs for the roster would be an urgent upgrade in their run defense which is one of the weakest in the NFL and possibly improvements at Center or Right Tackle on the O-line with Billy Price or Mike McGlinchey respective options. I originally projected Rashaan Evans as a middle linebacker to help the run defense but am toying with this weakness being addressed up-front instead by a run-stuffing defensive lineman here, especially with Da'Ron Payne still on the board.

However, the Chargers best linebacker Denzel Perryman struggles to stay fit and the rest of the group is middling at best. Rashaan Evans is instinctive, well coached and plays the run and pass with equal effectiveness. He has the versatility to be an every down linebacker and having played defensive end in high school those pass rush skills are visible in his game (recorded 15 sacks during his college career). He's arguably better suited to a 3-4 system so the Chargers could instead flip to Payne but I'll stick with Evans here.

Pick Fact : It's 20 years since the then San Diego Chargers picked one of the greatest draft busts of all-time. The Chargers gave up two first round picks, a second round pick, LB Patrick Sapp and Pro Bowler Eric Metcalf to move up to #2 overall to select QB Ryan Leaf who at the time signed the biggest ever rookie contract. Leaf was out of San Diego within 3 years and pretty much out of football a year later after two trades to Tampa and onto Dallas. Leaf's NFL career consisted of only 3,666 passing yards, 14 TD's and 36 interceptions.


18. Seattle Seahawks - DT Da'Ron Payne (Alabama)

Due to various trades the Seahawks don't pick again until #120 in the 4th round so they're prime candidates for a trade down to gather further picks. There's plenty of areas to address too with the Seahawks clearing out many of the high earners.

Assuming they're picking here at #18 top of the wish-list is surely help in the trenches on both sides of the ball. Whilst I think John Schneider will aggressively attempt to find a trade partner unless a top target is here, I have a no trade rule in my mock, so I'm going to select the lineman that's drawn comparisons to former Seahawk legend Cortez Kennedy.

Da'Ron Payne is probably the best run plugger in the draft and if he gets past the Chargers he could be in play here.

Pick Fact : If Da'Ron Payne gets selected in the first 32 picks, he'll be only the third Crimson Tide DT to be drafted in the first round, following in the footsteps of Mike Pitts (to Atlanta at #16 in 1983) and Marcell Dareus (to Buffalo at #3 in 2011)


19. Dallas Cowboys - LB Leighton Vander Esch (Boise State)

There's a few specific needs here - WR a definite need even before the release of Dez Bryant, a successor to Jason Witten which seems to be a perennial statement but also a testament to his longevity, and finally strengthening of the defensive line, but the Cowboys seem heavily interested in Boise State standout LB Leighton Vander Esch.

LVE is athletic but it's his play instincts that really standout. With 141 tackles in 14 games in 2017 he was always around the ball, demonstrating great play diagnosis as well as his athleticism.

The pick would make some sense as the Cowboys defense was noticeably worse once Sean Lee went down with injury (went from 18 points/game to 32 points/game surrendered) and in all of Lee's 7 yrs with the Cowboys he's yet to complete all 16 games in a single season. With Jaylon Smith continuing to bounceback, Vander Esch would add to the linebacker group and provide a succession plan as the on-field defensive QB.

Pick Fact : The 2018 NFL Draft marks the first time the event will be held within an NFL Stadium. Barring any trades this pick here will therefore be the first time a team has selected a player in the first round from within their own turf.


20. Detroit Lions - DT Taven Bryan (Florida)

The Lions pass rush was ranked 20th in the league in terms of sacks in 2017 and a primary focus of the draft will probably be to address this with multiple picks. If they're looking for an edge rusher they could consider Harold Landry or Marcus Davenport as both remain on my draft board. Both prospects are raw but Davenport could make some sense following the Lions hiring his college position coach this off season.

If the Lions consider the interior, then Taven Bryan would be a viable option. Bryan left Florida a year early and is also another developmental prospect but with outstanding athletic ability. Bryan could potentially play inside and at end and this versatility, combined with the departure of Haloti Ngata edges me more towards the former Gator.

Expect later round picks to also address the RB and TE positions, but I think it would be a little early here.

Pick Fact : It is 20 years since the Lions spent a first round pick on a defensive back (Terry Fair #20 overall in 1998) which is the longest current period of any NFL team.


21. Cincinnati Bengals - OT Mike McGlinchey (Notre Dame)

There are plenty of positions to fill on this Bengals roster. Hey I wouldn't entirely rule out a successor to the Ginger Prince if any of the top 5 QB's fall. However, I think the more likely of picks are to strengthen the O-line or D-line which brings in a number of candidates such as OT Connor Williams or DT Maurice Hurst or edge rusher Marcus Davenport.

However, the Bengals allowed Kevin Zeitler and Andrew Whitworth to depart via free agency and the offense suffered as a result. Andy Dalton was sacked 39 times and the run game inconsistent.

The Bengals have sought to address the line via a trade for Buffalo's Cordy Glenn but I still think they'll seek further help via the draft. On this basis I'm going to go with the Bengals selecting Quenton Nelson's left hand man Mike McGlinchey to re-enforce the Bengals o-line. McGlinchey is a 3-yr starter at Notre Dame with experience at both tackle positions. Whilst McGlinchey is seen as a left tackle he may be ideally suited on the opposite side which would be an immediate fit in Cincinnati.

Pick Fact : Mike McGlinchey is the cousin of Atlanta Falcons QB Matt Ryan

22. Buffalo Bills - OL Isaiah Wynn (Georgia)

With Buffalo earlier drafting their QB of the future in this mock, they can begin to fill their positions of need right now. There's a call for linebacker help but with the Bills trading LT Cordy Glenn and both C Eric Wood and LG Richie Incognito retiring there is a strong need for further re-enforcements.

Georgia's Isaiah Wynn has experience at left tackle and at Guard. Despite Wynn's light feet, at 6'3 and shortish arm length he's more likely suited to Guard in the pro's but his versatility and college experience make him an immediate plug and play starter.

With LeSean McCoy the focal point of the offense there's a possibility the Bills could consider UTEP's Will Hernandez as an alternative pick at the position whose a superior run blocker but I think Wynn is more technically sound NFL ready and the Bills need immediate contributors.

Pick Fact :  Should the Bills retain both their first round picks, this will be the fourth occasion in the last 15 years where Buffalo have doubled up on picks in the first round


23. New England Patriots - OT Connor Williams (Texas)

The Patriots trade of Brandin Cooks has some wondering if Bill Belichick is planning to engineer a significant move up the draft to acquire a specific target. I've even heard rumours of capital to trade for OBJ. Both options seem against the grain to me but I don't rule anything out from the master himself.

I think the most pressing needs are on the front seven of the defense and finding a replacement for Nate Solder who joined the Giants via free agency.

The Patriots efforts at drafting an insurance policy for Solder in the 2017 draft back-fired with Conor McDermott (Rd6) released and Antonio Garcia (Rd4) spending the year out with a non-football related condition. I think they'll have to re-address the position earlier in this draft. Connor Williams is ranked by some as the best tackle available this year, so if the Patriots have him ranked similarly they could pounce here. There's also some mentions of their interest in UCLA's 6'9 tackle Kolton Miller as potential alternative to Williams.

Pick Fact : They say Belichick never drafts o-linemen in the first round. Well he did in 2011 when he selected Nate Solder #17 overall. That pick also happened to be the only 1st round pick spent on an offensive player by the Patriots since 2006 (RB Laurence Maloney at #21)


24. Carolina Panthers - CB Isaiah Oliver (Colorado)

My initial thoughts here were for the Panthers to address their dire need for WR help, especially a true #1 receiver. I thought candidates such as D.J Moore could add explosion or Courtland Sutton as a typical rangy type that has previously been drafted to compensate for Cam Newton's liberal passing. I also considered an attempt to plug their biggest free agency loss, the outstanding Guard Andrew Norwell. However, in both instances I feel that there is really good value later in the draft and thoroughly expect Carolina to expend picks at these positions, probably in rounds 2 and 3.

With Daryl Worley traded to the Eagles and his targeted free agency replacement Bashaud Breeland failing a medical I'm instead switching attention to a host of possible cornerbacks to fill another need position. The previous Dave Gettleman regime didn't value defensive backs that highly but in the NFC South it's important to be able to mirror the likes of Julio Jones, Mike Evans and Michael Thomas, all of whom come in at over 6'3.

There's a number of guys who could be up for consideration such as Mike Hughes, Jaire Alexander and Carlton Davis but I'm going to go for the bigger guy of the remaining bunch and see the Panthers select Colorado's Isaiah Oliver. The downside may be that Oliver might not be an immediate plug-in starter but has the athleticism, size, speed and length that is coveted in the modern cornerback and the potential to become a bump-and-run type blanket cover guy that becomes worth his weight in gold in a pass-heavy division.

Pick Fact : The Panthers have not selected a defensive back in the 1st round since Chris Gamble back in 2004


25. Tennessee Titans - EDGE Harold Landry (Boston College)

The Titans are another team in need of WR help but I'm just not feeling it in the first round this year. They also need pass rush help. Jurrell Casey is a keeper at defensive end but Brian Orakpo and Derrick Morgan are not getting any younger on the edge and 2016 second rounder Kevin Dodd approaches bust status and would seem a much better fit in a conventional 4-3.

I have the Titans taking the raw prospect Harold Landry who has drawn some comparisons with Vic Beasley in terms of his burst around the edge. Landry may find himself suffering in similar vein to Beasley in terms of his best use either as a stand up rusher or his hand in the ground but as his 16.5 sacks at BC in 2016 hint at, he has high end potential if he can bring it all together in the pro's.

Pick Fact : The franchises first ever draft pick (as the Houston Oilers) was to select Mike Ditka #8 overall in the 1961 AFL Draft. Ditka was also selected by the Bears #5 overall in the 1961 NFL Draft and elected to begin his Hall of Fame career in Chicago instead.


26. Atlanta Falcons - DT Maurice Hurst (Michigan)

The Falcons will use the draft to top-up a strong roster but I have no doubt that the interior of the defensive line is the absolute priority early and possibly often in this draft. Grady Jarrett returns from 2017 but after him only Jack Crawford remains on this roster from last year and he spent practically all of it on IR.

The Falcons may feel pressure to trade up to ensure they obtain one of the top defensive tackles in this years crop but by chance and also by way of a health concern identified at the combine that made Maurice Hurst miss out on the drills, I still have him available here at #26 and if so, I don't think the Falcons would pass on the opportunity unless their medical staff are duly concerned.

Hurst is lightning fast for an interior lineman with quick feet and hands but has a relatively slight frame for the position and could be exposed against power running schemes and mauling guards.

If Atlanta do pull the trigger on Hurst here I think they'll still look for another DT offering more bulk and run plug skills further down this draft class. Dan Quinn has publicly stated he feels there is a lot of depth on the defensive line in this class so I wouldn't be surprised to see some later picks continuing to address the current lack of depth.

Pick Fact : In the Dan Quinn era the Falcons have used each of their first two draft picks in all three drafts thus far on defensive players.


27. New Orleans Saints -  WR D.J Moore (Maryland)

With the improvements seen in the D in 2017 maybe it's time for the Saints to switch attention to the other side of the ball. I think the focus would likely be on a pass catcher or interior lineman. If the Saints do look to bolster the o-line I think Will Hernandez or James Daniels could be valuable additions on the interior.

At the tight end position Coby Fleener has largely been a disappointment with only 22 catches last year, 37 year old Ben Watson was signed on a 1-yr deal. There's some depth with Josh Hill and Michael Hoomanawanui but they're mainly blockers. The Saints have lacked a difference maker at the position since Jimmy Graham departed but the Watson signing probably lessens the urgency though I'm not discounting the organisation falling for someone like Mike Gesicki, Dallas Goedert or Hayden Hurst.


However based on overall depth at TE, I've the Saints taking a young WR here instead. It looks like the Saints won't match the Ravens offer sheet for Willie Snead and Ted Ginn isn't getting any younger.
Time to bring another difference maker into the fold.

D.J Moore posted 1033 receiving yards and 8 TD's despite an injury ravaged QB situation for the Terrapins (Moore caught passes from 4 different QB's) and has an uncanny ability to make people miss once he has the ball in hand. His route running needs refinement but he has the potential to be that difference maker.
p
Pick Fact : If D.J Moore gets selected in the first round, he'll be the first Maryland Terrapin to get drafted that high since fellow WR Darrius Heyward-Bey in 2009


28. Pittsburgh Steelers -  S Justin Reid (Stanford)

The Steelers are likely to focus early picks on the defensive side of the ball. There was a definite drop-off in play down the stretch and the Steelers could honestly benefit from a depth and/or upgrades on the d-line, linebackers and secondary.

Justin Reid has been garnering interest from a lot of teams sitting late in the first round. Super athletic, he has the instincts to help in man coverage and some ball-hawking skills as his 5 interceptions in 2017 demonstrate. The younger brother of recently released 49ers safety Eric Reid (selected #18 overall in 2013) Justin isn't at his brothers standard yet, and to that end might be a first round reach, but would instantly impact the Pittsburgh secondary regardless.

Pick Fact : The Steelers lay claim to the greatest ever draft class. Seven players from the 1974 draft class made the Hall of Fame - four of those were drafted by Pittsburgh. Their first 3 picks Lynn Swann (#21), Jack Lambert (#46) and John Stallworth (#82) and fifth round pick Mike Webster (#125) all deservedly made it to Canton.


29. Jacksonville Jaguars - OG Will Hernandez (Texas El Paso)

Whilst the Jaguars coaching staff managed to coax the best out of Blake Bortles down the stretch they've hedged their bets on taking his 5th year option rather than agreeing to a long term deal. I think they'll see how this season pans out before making a final decision on Bortles so I will ignore clamour for QB to be the pick here. Despite the Jags owning a top-notch defense I could see further strengthening via a slot corner and Central Florida's Mike Hughes would be an amazing selection. Similarly I could see some succession planning on the d-line which is a position of strength but figures to be a position of aging higher priced vets down the line.

However, I'll go with Coughlin continuing to lay down a marker with smash-mouth players on offense and with arguably their weakest link on the offensive line A.J Cann hitting free agency after this year there's additional reasoning. An immediate potential upgrade via Will Hernandez of Texas El Paso would be an option. Only Quenton Nelson in this class is arguably a better run blocker and whilst Hernandez may not be the most athletic he would seem to fit the Jaguars mould and owns an aggressive streak that would appeal to Tom Coughlin. I also wouldn't entirely rule out Ohio State's Billy Price who could offer center/guard versatility and bring his own known nasty streak to Florida.

Pick Fact : If Will Hernandez does indeed get drafted in the 1st round it would be the first time a Texas El Paso draftee has been picked this high since 1968 when incidentally both Fred Carr (#5 overall) and George Daney (#22 overall) were selected in the first round. They remain the only UTEP Miners to be selected in the 1st round of an NFL draft. Even if Hernandez gets drafted outside of round one, he will become only the second player drafted out of UTEP in the last 10 years (RB Aaron Jones was selected #182 by the Pack in 2017)


30. Minnesota Vikings -  CB Mike Hughes (Central Florida)

This is a strong roster but the Vikes have a couple of potential issues to address. My initial feel here was for the Vikes to focus on the corner position where Central Florida's Mike Hughes may be an ideal fit. He is ideally suited as a slot corner and should straight away step into the role that Mackensie Alexander has struggled to fill since he was drafted 2nd round in 2016.

This would give Minnesota even more frightening secondary depth to an all star cast that already includes Xavier Rhodes, Trae Waynes and Harrison Smith.

However, I'm being swayed from this pick (I think) and towards O-line help following the retirement of RG Joe Berger. The Vikes may switch Mike Remmers to guard or address via the draft. Either way, it's possible they could have an o-lineman still on the board with a first round grade, possibly James Daniels who has experience at both guard and center who would make a viable alternative.

Pick Fact : In 2003 the Minnesota Vikings were on the clock to pick at #7 but did not hand in their selection in the 15 minute timeframe. In the meantime both the Panthers and Jaguars leapfrogged the Vikings taking Jordan Gross and Byron Leftwich at #7 and #8 respectively. The Vikes later stated it was due to a failed trade attempt with the Ravens and of course claimed they had selected the player they wanted all along. It wasn't a bad selection when they finally picked at #9 with Kevin Williams eventually playing 11 years for the Vikes.


31. New England Patriots -  CB Carlton Davis (Auburn)

Is this the pick where New England annoint Tom Brady's eventual successor?

Mason Rudolph is still on my draft board and could be the type of QB to prosper in New England. He has ideal size at 6'5 and 235, a decent enough arm and demonstrated significant year-on-year improvements in his 3 years starting in college.

Rudolph has been invited to work out for New England but a deciding factor could be on whether the organisation believe he has the ability to take the leap from a simplified offense at Oklahoma State to the Patriots pro offense.

I think Rudolph could be the surprise pick but also suspect the Patriots will be strongly tempted to fill more immediate needs in the quest for another Super Bowl in the Tom Brady era and Carlton Davis fits the typical Patriots mould of a cornerback coming in at around 6'1 and over 200lbs. 

Pick Fact : It's 10 years since the Patriots drafted an Auburn Tiger, CB Jonathan Wilhite in the 4th round


32. Philadelphia Eagles -  TE Mike Gesicki (Penn State)

The defending Super Bowl champions don't appear to have many holes to fill on the roster at first glance and may have the luxury of selecting the best player available at #32.

In terms of needs, a successor for Jason Peters may still be on the cards although Halapoulivaati Vaitai improved with every game in 2017. They may also look to bring in an additional RB with the departure of LeGarrette Blount and the jury still out on last years rookie pick Donnel Pumphrey, not forgetting Jay Ajayi enters a contract year.

It seems likely that the Eagles are looking to trade down from #32 bearing in mind that otherwise they wouldn't pick again until #130 in a class that appears to have a lot of quality depth in rounds 2 and 3. However, my mock does not allow this option.

With that in mind, the Eagles took a double hit with the free agency departure of Trey Burton and the salary cap driven release of Brent Celek. Doug Pederson's offense tends to utilise a lot of two tight end sets so I was leaning to the Eagles replacing their losses with someone like Mike Gesicki who blew up the combine with an off the charts performance. Gesicki wouldn't be much of a run blocker but then again Zach Ertz has never been asked to do too much in that respect either. However, whilst this option is not blown away in it's entirety, the signing of Richard Rodgers maybe makes it less of an urgent need but more of a medium term move. 

Pick Fact : The Eagles hold the distinction of drafting the first ever player in the inaugural draft in 1936. They selected the "one man football team" from the University of Chicago, Jay Berwanger, who ended up never playing a game in the NFL, instead choosing to work for the Chicago Rubber Company.

Wednesday, 7 June 2017

Initial Draft Grades 2017 - NFC North








1 (2). North Carolina QB Mitchell Trubisky
2 (45). Ashland TE Adam Shaheen
4 (112). Alabama S Eddie Jackson
4 (119). North Carolina A&T RB Tarik Cohen
5 (147). Kutztown OG Jordan Morgan


Good Move - Moving the draft from Chicago to Philly. It possibly saved the Bears Front Office getting lynched by their fans in their hometown. For me, the Bears made too many questionable trade moves and suspect selections in this class which was surprising after a few solid drafts.
Bargain Pick - Eddie Jackson was the only selection I liked, falling out of the top 100 due to a season ending injury in college. Jackson could fill my Good Move, Bargain Pick and Risk/Reward gamble category as a result. The Bears urgently need secondary help in this division and Jackson should contribute.
Risk / Reward Gamble - Adam Shaheen from small Division II Ashland was a surprise as high as #45. At 6'6 and 280 lbs he's a Frankenstein-like target at TE and shown good athleticism and speed at the combine. I'd be concerned at both the step up in competition and question why his blocking should be so poor for a man of his size.
Tell Me Why Again - No-one appeared sold on a sure-fire franchise QB in this years class, yet the Bears, despite seemingly having secured a starting QB in free agency, surrendered picks #67, #111 and a 2018 3rd rounder for a move up just one place in the draft to take a QB with only 13 career starts in college. If Trubisky proves to be their franchise QB, good for the Bears. However, the picks lost to move up just that one place when the 49ers were pretty obviously not going to take a QB left me puzzled.








1 (21). Florida LB Jarrad Davis
2 (53). Florida CB Teez Tabor
3 (96). Northern Illinois WR Kenny Golladay
4 (124). Tennessee OLB Jalen Reeves-Maybin
4 (127). Toledo TE Michael Roberts
5 (165). San Diego CB Jamal Agnew
6 (205). Arkansas DE Jeremiah Ledbetter
6 (215). Miami (FL) QB Brad Kaaya
7 (250). Eastern Michigan DT Pat O’Connor

Good Move - The Lions has arguably the worst linebacking unit in the NFL in 2016. They've made free agency moves for depth and landed an instant starter upgrade in Jarrad Davis in the 1st round. Reeves-Maybin was added in the 4th but carries injury concerns. He's a project but again good on the Lions for addressing the need at linebacker.
Bargain Pick - Michael Roberts caught 16 TD's in his final year at Toledo. I'm not going to kid anyone here and pretend he can replicate that in the pro's. What Roberts' will provide is a big bodied TE2/TE3 who can run block and has good hands if called upon in the pass game.
Risk / Reward Gamble - Teez Tabor was mooted as a possible 1st round pick until running a 4.62 at the combine and a 4.75 at his pro-day. For some this confirmed the whispers that his lack of top-end speed leaves him afraid of the deep ball. Add into the mix criticisms of weak tackling and suspensions over drug tests and an altercation with a team-mate and you've got some pretty big questions marks to off-set his 28 passes defensed and 9 picks during his college career.
Tell Me Why Again - I was really surprised the Lions didn't address the pass-rush in the 1st round with McKinley, Harris and Charlton still on the board. I'm not knocking the selection of Davis, LB was a need and there was plenty of depth in this class of edge rushers for Detroit to defer an obviously urgent need. However, it became a total head-scratcher when they then waited until the 6th round to attempt to address the pass rush.








2 (33). Washington CB Kevin King
2 (61). North Carolina State SS Josh Jones
3 (93). Auburn DL Montravius Adams
4 (108). Wisconsin OLB Vince Biegel
4 (134). Brigham Young RB Jamaal Williams
5 (175). Purdue WR DeAngelo Yancey
5 (182). Texas El-Paso RB Aaron Jones
6 (212). South Florida G/C Kofi Amichia
7 (238). Utah State RB Devante Mays
7 (247). LSU WR Malachi Dupre

Good Move - The Packers went defense early, maybe pre-occupied with nightmares of Julio Jones running all over them and clearly drafted for size and athleticism in the selections of King and Jones. Both players should hopefully be pushing for starting roles by the start of week one.
Bargain Pick - Jamaal Williams has a bruising, aggressive style which could prove to be a great foil for WR turned RB Ty Montgomery. The Packers don't know how Montgomery will handle a full season in the backfield, so whilst Williams will likely spell Montgomery he's demonstrated at BYU that he can handle a full workload.
Risk / Reward Gamble - Originally a top 5 high school defensive recruit, Montravius Adams never really hit his potential at Auburn and carries a bit of the underachiever tag. Can the Packers get the best out of him consistently? His combine numbers were just ok and together with his college production I think Adams was picked too high
Tell Me Why Again - Did the defensive co-ordinator and offensive co-ordinator take shifts at turning in the picks? Initially four defensive players picked, then the draft rounded off with six successive offensive players. And three RB's selected.... really? OK there's a need for depth at the position in Green Bay so I'll give them a little leeway on that.











2 (41). Florida State RB Dalvin Cook
3 (70). Ohio State G/C Pat Elflein
4 (109). Iowa DT Jaleel Johnson
4 (120). Michigan LB Ben Gedeon
5 (170). South Florida WR Rodney Adams
5 (180). Miami (FL) OG Danny Isidora
6 (201). Virginia Tech TE Bucky Hodges
7 (219). Miami (FL) WR Stacy Coley
7 (220). Northwestern DE Ifeadi Odenigbo
7 (232). Kansas State LB Elijah Lee
7 (245). North Carolina State CB Jack Tocho

Good Move - I'm struggling to find a problem with this class. Sensible trades up to secure Cook and Elflein, understandable trades down to acquire additional picks later on to add competition for roster spots. Dalvin Cook was a top 10 1st round talent who unexpectedly fell into the 2nd round after posting less than stellar combine numbers. Elflein is a likely day one starter. Add-in the first round pick sent to the Eagles for Sam Bradford and this class looks better still.
Bargain Pick - Like Cook, Jaleel Johnson was another player who didn't light up the combine but was a consistently solid performer at Iowa. A high motor and excellent hands, working with a coach in Mike Zimmer who knows how to get the best out of defenders will benefit him enormously.
Risk / Reward Gamble - The risk is mitigated here with this being the 201st pick, but Bucky Hodges brings off-field baggage as part of this pick but had a really strong combine and has the size and all the athletic traits to succeed in the NFL. Pat Shurmer likes to utilise TE's in his offense and Hodges is one of the new breed of WR/TE hybrids but with the additional capacity to block in-line too.
Tell Me Why Again - Why can't the Vikes better their 8-8 record from last year? A solid draft class and key moves in free agency have only strengthened this roster. It will be vital that 2016 1st rounder Laquon Treadwell takes a huge leap (1 catch for 15 yards as a rookie) otherwise the passing offense will continue to suffer through lack a playmakers.

Tuesday, 6 June 2017

Initial Draft Grades 2017 - NFC East








1 (28). Michigan DE Taco Charlton
2 (60). Colorado CB Chidobe Awuzie
3 (92). Michigan CB Jourdan Lewis
4 (133). North Carolina WR Ryan Switzer
6 (191). Louisiana Tech S Xavier Woods
6 (216). Florida State CB Marquez White
7 (228). Florida DT Joey Ivie
7 (239). Ohio State WR Noah Brown
7 (246). Colorado DT Jordan Carrell

Good Move - The Cowboys needed help in their secondary and threw 4 of their first 6 picks at defensive backs. I usually criticise such moves but all 4 guys offer positional versatility at an area of need. For the class to be a success, they'll need contributions in the secondary from at least some of this class of defensive backs and all 4 guys do have the potential to succeed on this roster.
Bargain Pick - Xavier Woods was a Cowboy favourite so the pick wasn't a surprise. What he lacks in size/speed he makes up for with positional versatility and on-field production. It will be interesting to see how Rod Marinelli chooses to use him as a chess piece in the secondary.
Risk / Reward Gamble - Jourdan Lewis was a possible 1st round talent but his draft stock fell due to a potential domestic violence charge that hangs over him. 
Tell Me Why Again - The Cowboys had a need for an edge rusher but with VP Stephen Jones admitting Charlton didn't carry a first round grade on their board, the pick feels like a positional reach. Despite Charlton being only a 1-year starter he's got talent and could make this a good pick. I'm more bothered by the VP openly admitting the reach.








1 (23). Ole Miss TE Evan Engram
2 (55). Alabama DT Dalvin Tomlinson
3 (87). California QB Davis Webb
4 (140). Clemson RB Wayne Gallman
5 (167). Youngstown State DE Avery Moss
6 (200). Pittsburgh OT Adam Bisnowaty

Good Move - I wasn't overly impressed with the draft class but with questions over Eli Manning's 2016 down season and/or decline, at least the Giants provided some weapons in Engram and Gallman and shown a nod to the future with the Webb pick.
Bargain Pick - Wayne Gallman was the leading rusher on the successful Clemson programme for 3 years and with the Giants operating a similar spread system he will hope to transfer his college production into the pro's. His game has lots of question marks to it, but the Giants was a good fit.
Risk / Reward Gamble - Taking Evan Engram at #23 was a surprise with David Njoku (who I thought to be the better blocker and more dynamic receiver) still on the board. Engram wasn't asked to block at Ole Miss and lined up mainly in the slot. He's more of an oversized receiver at this point but could still provide Manning with a viable situational target.
Tell Me Why Again - Too many questions remain after this draft. Why was the first o-line selection at #200 when the Giants have arguably one of the worst o-lines in the NFL? Is Davis Webb really a candidate to be the eventual replacement for Eli Manning? 




 




1 (14). Tennessee DE Derek Barnett
2 (43). Washington CB Sidney Jones
3 (99). West Virginia CB Rasul Douglas
4 (118). North Carolina WR Mack Hollins
4 (132). San Diego State RB Donnel Pumphrey
5 (166). West Virginia WR Shelton Gibson
5 (184). Nebraska S Nate Gerry
6 (214). Washington DT Elijah Qualls

Good Move - Edge rusher was a positional need and it felt fitting that Derek Barnett who broke Reggie White's sack record at Tennessee should end up in Philly. I'm not putting the hex on Barnett with a foolish player comparison to the all-time great but it was a sensible pick and understandable with McCaffrey and Lattimore off the board. Jonathan Allen was still available at #14 but the Front Office must have seen Barnett as a better system fit. Let's not forget the pre-draft, obtaining Timmy Jernigan in return for the Eagles #74 pick.
Bargain Pick - Nate Gerry lacks top end speed and agility but is a tough hombre. The Eagles have space at safety but are likely to look at him as a hybrid LB type if he can bulk up. His special teams play should ensure he makes the 53 man roster and I'll be intrigued to see if/how Jim Schwartz utilises him on gameday.
Risk / Reward Gamble - Sidney Jones was a potential top half of first round pick before his torn achilles. He'll be a popular 'steal' pick by experts but with the injury in mind, it feels a gamble to take him as high as #43. Jones may not play in 2017 and there's certainly no guarantee he'll be the player he was. It's a great pick if he fully returns but there's no guarantee. The Eagles subsequent selection of Rasul Douglas reflected their understanding of the inherent risk of the Jones pick.
Tell Me Why Again - This Eagles team is crying out for a 3-down back to help alleviate the pressure on the development of Carson Wentz. They failed to address this during the draft. Pumphrey was very productive in college but realistically is a Sproles-lite option and his possible eventual successor. The Eagles missed out on McCaffrey in round 1 but when Dalvin Cook surprisingly slid into round 2 I'd expected a move up by the Eagles but it was not to be.








1 (17). Alabama DL Jonathan Allen
2 (49). Alabama OLB Ryan Anderson
3 (81). UCLA CB Fabian Moreau
4 (114). Oklahoma RB Samaje Perine
4 (123). Michigan State S Montae Nicholson
5 (154). Arkansas TE Jeremy Sprinkle
6 (199). Wyoming G/C Chase Roullier
6 (209). Georgia State WR Robert Davis
7 (230). Louisville S Josh Harvey-Clemons
7 (235). Auburn CB Joshua Holsey

Good Move - Jonathan Allen carried a top 5 grade but injury concerns saw him fall into the middle of the 1st round. The Skins wouldn't have expected him to be available here and will believe they've got themselves a day one steal. Allen will immediately have an opportunity to bolster one of the weaker D-lines in the NFC. They stayed with the Crimson Tide on the 2nd day also and Allen's team-mate Ryan Anderson is an aggressive edge rusher who also fits a need in the capital.
Bargain Pick - A solid pick of Jeremy Sprinkle in the 5th round. He'll back-up oft-injured Jordan Reed and the aging Vernon Davis who saw a renaissance in 2016. Sprinkle could become one of the best blocking tight ends available from this draft class and has decent hands too. He may not excel in any one department but is a well rounded prospect who should have a chance to contribute. 
Risk / Reward Gamble - Fabian Moreau is a classic boom or bust pick. He posted great numbers at the combine, was a 3-yr starter at UCLA and has the size, fluidity and tackling skills that could have seen him become a 1st round pick. The knock on Moreau however is on his coverage limitations where he predominantly played cover-3, reflected with only 3 interceptions in his 37 career starts. If the coaches can harness the tools and improve his awareness they'll have a steal.
Tell Me Why Again - Despite a solid overall draft class, I was surprised that the Redskins failed to address inside linebacker or add some QB depth. The Skins have some potential challenges coming up in free agency next year at both these positions but they weren't addressed at any point.



Monday, 5 June 2017

Initial Draft Grades 2017 - NFC South











1 (26). UCLA DE Takkarist McKinley
3 (75). LSU LB Duke Riley
4 (136). Oregon State T/G Sean Harlow
5 (149). San Diego State CB Damontae Kazee
5 (156). Wyoming RB Brian Hill
5 (174). Drake TE Eric Saubert

Good Move - A balanced draft in terms of offense and defensive mix which addressed positions of need on both sides of the ball. The Falcons remained consistent with their template of fast, aggressive defensive players and looked to add depth on offense. Their best move was arguably the first round trade up to ensure they obtained one of the remaining edge rushers with first round grades once pass rushers began to fall from the board. Takk McKinley is raw but improved each year. He potentially forms a fearsome pass rush tandem on the edge opposite Vic Beasley.
Bargain Pick - Demontae Kazee has ball skills far higher than the 5th round, with 43 passes defensed and 16 interceptions during his last 3 years in college. He probably lacks the size or top end speed to play outside so has been muted as a possible nickel corner by scouts. I think he could also be viewed as a potential free safety in Atlanta's system. Under Quinn's guidance he could prove a steal.
Risk / Reward Gamble - Duke Riley is a one year starter in college who replaced Deion Jones (Atlanta's 2016 second round pick) at LSU. Riley's inexperienced and seems more suited as an inside fit like Jones, but he fits the Atlanta template of fast and aggressive at LB.
Tell Me Why Again - Why didn't the Falcons run the ball more in the second half of Superbowl? Hard to question the picks as they all addressed specific areas of need and after smashing the last few drafts who are we to argue? From a personal perspective I felt that the O-line could have been addressed earlier. Riley will likely play a rotational role in 2017 whereas Atlanta needs a full time starter at guard to replace the retired Chris Chester.









1 (8). Stanford RB Christian McCaffrey
2 (40). Ohio State WR/RB Curtis Samuel
2 (64). Western Michigan OT Taylor Moton
3 (77). Texas A&M DE Daeshon Hall
5 (152). Miami (FL) CB Corn Elder
6 (192). West Georgia FB Alexander Armah
7 (233). Georgia Tech K Harrison Butker

Good Move - Prioritising the top end of the draft to help out Cam Newton. McCaffrey is the most versatile back in the draft and Curtis Samuel should provide a nice foil and insurance option. As well as the skill positions they also added Taylor Moton to help protect Newton and the Panthers will hope he works his way into the starting o-line at either Right Tackle or Guard by opening day.
Bargain Pick - Corn Elder is undersized corner but has the skills and smarts to make the teams nickel packages and should be a valuable contributor on special teams. Good value in the 5th.
Risk / Reward Gamble - Myles Garrett's college sidekick Daeshon Hall is very raw with limited experience on the D-line but plenty of potential. The D-line is a position of strength in Carolina, so this could either give Hall valuable time to develop or worst case stunt his development by limiting his opportunities for valuable game time.
Tell Me Why Again - Why do the Panthers keep double dipping? Last years draft class saw them take 3 corners, this year both their top 40 picks were spent on running backs. I get it that not all draftees are going to make it, so is this clever insurance or lack of confidence in the scouting dept?








1 (11). Ohio State CB Marshon Lattimore
1 (32). Wisconsin OT Ryan Ramczyk
2 (42). Utah FS Marcus Williams
3 (67). Tennessee RB Alvin Kamara
3 (76). Florida LB Alex Anzalone
3 (103). Florida Atlantic DE Trey Hendrickson
6 (196). Miami (FL) DE Al-Quadin Muhammad

Good Move - Despite only one year as a starter, Marshon Lattimore was arguably the best cornerback in the draft. I doubt the Saints expected him to be available outside of the top 10 but the run on QB's fell favourably for New Orleans. There's some injury concerns over Lattimore's hamstring but he has the tools to be a potential lock-down corner in a pass heavy division. 
Bargain Pick - Trey Hendrickson was ultra productive in college and whilst we hear the "short arms / average height" comments from the scouting community, if you prefer game tape to measurables you'd say he has a real chance to contribute 
Risk / Reward Gamble  - Alex Anzalone is a gifted athlete with potential to become an every down linebacker in New Orleans. This has to be weighed up against repeated shoulder/arm injuries at Florida which raise long-term durability questions.
Tell Me Why Again - Why didn't the Saints address the pass-rush as an earlier priority? I also question the move for Alvin Kamara but Sean Payton loved him. The Saints sacrificed their 2018 second rounder in addition to the 67th pick used to take Kamara. Now I like him as a back and he'll provide some versatility but there seemed to be more pressing needs on a consistently poor defense than adding to a backfield already consisting of Mark Ingram and now Adrian Peterson.









1 (19). Alabama TE O.J. Howard
2 (50). Texas A&M S Justin Evans
3 (84). Penn State WR Chris Godwin
3 (107). LSU ILB Kendell Beckwith
5 (162). Boise State RB Jeremy McNichols
7 (223). USC DT Stevie Tu’ikolovatu

Good Move - NFC South take note of the targets GM Jason Licht is providing Jameis Winston. Desean Jackson was added in free agency, O.J Howard, Chris Godwin and Jeremy McNicols added in the draft class. All should contribute to the passing game in 2017.
Bargain Pick - It's a reach to suggest O.J Howard is a bargain at #19 maybe - but did anyone expect him to fall to Tampa? He can block, he can catch and he has speed to stretch defensive seams. Day one starter at a position of need. Was a great win for Tampa early in the draft.
Risk / Reward Gamble - Beckwith is solely an inside linebacker but was a good one on a strong LSU defense. Likely restricted to a 2-down LB role, he tore his ACL at the back-end of his final season on campus which affected his draft stock. 
Tell Me Why Again - I expected O-line depth to be addressed but this was completely ignored. I figured RB to also be a priority due to off-field issues surrounding Doug Martin. Instead McNichols was taken at #162 who is a decent receiver but similar to back-up Jacquizz Rodgers, and not the bell-cow inside rusher that would appear to be needed as insurance. Tampa has to be confident that Doug Martin is good to go in 2017.

Thursday, 27 April 2017

NFL Mock Draft 2017

Colin Bell's Mock Draft 2017



Time again for another wild shot in the dark carefully labelled as a mock draft ahead of the 2017 NFL Draft. 

Nice straight forward rules as ever - no trades projected unless confirmed prior to draft, once off the board a player can't be projected as a pick to another team. 

With that said, let's get into the guesses educated projections........


1. Cleveland Browns - DE Myles Garrett (Texas A&M)


Myles Garrett is the consensus #1 prospect heading into the draft and supplemented his reputation with an outstanding combine. He posted 31 sacks and a further 35 hurries in his college career and improved against the run each year. There's some scout smoke around his motor and whether he was that dominant against top-level competition but he has the tool set to potentially become an All Pro very quickly.

Yes the Browns need a QB too, so it's typical Browns luck that this is a draft class that lacks that sure-fire franchise QB. The Browns can ill afford another 1st round QB reach (see Johnny Manziel, Brandon Weeden and Brady Quinn during the last decade alone), so picking #1 they should take the widely regarded best player available. I think they'll be tempted (for tempted maybe read into that as desperate) on QB, but I believe Garrett should be the selection barring any blockbuster trade.


2. San Francisco 49ers - S Jamal Adams (LSU)

The new Front Office and coaching staff in San Francisco face their first opportunity to improve a roster that has significantly deteriorated since the 49ers last Superbowl appearance only 5 years ago. Like the Browns, there is a strong need for a QB here and the decision makers in the organisation have the security of 6-yr contracts to invest some development time into a rookie QB.

However, unless the 49ers love one of the rookie passers such as Mitchell Trubisky, the #2 pick may be too high for the cream of this QB class. The Front Office were quick to add a couple of veteran QB's in free agency (Brian Hoyer / Matt Barkley) that lead me to believe they are bridge QB's ahead of the ultimate target of Kirk Cousins in free agency 2018.

If the 49ers stay at #2, I think Jonathan Allen or Solomon Thomas could improve the pass rush and contribute to the formation of a young, potentially fearsome front with DeForest Buckner and Erik Armstead, or they could look to secondary help via cornerback Marshon Lattimore but I'm leaning towards new GM John Lynch leaning toward his old playing position with both Jamal Adams or Malik Hooker viable options at Safety. Hooker appears to be the best ball-playing safety of the two but Adams is a real tone setter on gameday with outstanding leadership skills.

Should the 49ers select either Adams or Hooker it would be the highest selection of a safety since the Browns selected the now sadly departed Eric Turner at #2 in 1991.


3. Chicago Bears - DE Solomon Thomas (Stanford)

The Bears went from 6-10 in 2015 to 3-13 in 2016 with their 3rd string QB at the helm. Despite the regression in their win-loss record there were sufficient signs of promise coming out of Soldier Field.

The enigmatic and problematic Jay Cutler was given his release and free agent signing Mike Glennon heads over from Tampa Bay. With the QB position apparently addressed, it leaves me thinking that
the strongest need is for further playmakers on defense in a division that sees them face Aaron Rodgers and Matt Stafford twice.

Improving the pass-rush or the secondary depth would seem a wise investment. I'm not sure if the edge rushers in this class not named Myles Garrett warrant a top 5 selection but the relentless Solomon Thomas should be a safe pick on an area of need for the Bears. He can probably play end or interior lineman and is a 3-down option. I don't discount standout corner Marshon Lattimore here either.


4. Jacksonville Jaguars - RB Leonard Fournette (LSU)

As is tradition with my opening statement when it comes to the Jaguars mocked pick, I like to point out how this is now the 10th consecutive season Jacksonville own a pick in the top 10 of the first round. In the era of parity this is a revealing statistic on how consistently poor they've been in Jacksonville during the last decade.

Owner Shad Khan's patience finally seems to have been eroded and the regime change may not be given as much time as Gus Bradley enjoyed. Blake Bortles regressed in 2016 and it's important he bounces back. I can see the Jaguars seeking some QB insurance in the middle rounds of this years draft.

As for Rd1, I'd like to see them help Bortles rekindle his mojo with a significant upgrade at RB courtesy of Leonard Fournette, who could have success similar to Ezekiel Elliott's rookie year. Fournette is a proper bruiser of a runner and would happily carry the workload in Jacksonville.

If Fournette isn't the pick, the Jags still don't consistently pressure QB's despite the growing talent on their roster, so I could foresee an addition to the D-line rotation such as Jonathan Allen or Solomon Thomas as viable, but I will be groaning out loud if the Jags pass on Fournette.


5. Tennessee Titans - CB Marshon Lattimore (Ohio State)

The Titans broke .500 for the first time since 2011 and are showing real signs of life with talent in key areas on the roster. I believe this pick has to focus on either the secondary or by offering Marcus Mariota a serious weapon at WR1.

Clemson's Mike Williams would be an intriguing option at WR or they could look towards the blazing Desean Jackson clone John Ross. However, I can't overlook the fact that the Titans ranked 32nd in yards allowed to teams WR1 and also ranked 32nd for yards allowed to teams WR2.

Cornerback help is vital and despite some concerns over previous hamstring injuries, QB's posted only a 30.2 rating when throwing against Lattimore in 2016. Marshon Lattimore appears to be the consensus potential lock down corner in the draft class. If he's off the board I still think the Titans stay with cornerback or safety here, knowing they have an additional first round pick at #18 to provide Mariota with a receiving target.


6. New York Jets - S Malik Hooker (Ohio State)

The Jets are openly canvassing suitors for this pick as they enter full rebuild mode. If they have no takers, I'd suggest help for whoever is QB in the Big Apple next year. I'd consider QB a pick here but the Jets have drafted one in each of the last 4 years and at some point they have to let their picks play themselves out.

With the team having questions over QB they'd better be able to run the ball. Leonard Fournette would have been the ideal pick for the Jets but if he's gone the Jets may consider Dalvin Cook but it's been 12 years since two RB's went this high and the Jets may feel they can still obtain value from a RB in later rounds.

With Fournette gone, let's project the Jets going with best player available and taking the ball-hawking Malik Hooker who has drawn favourable comparisons with Ed Reed. He carries some questions on his tackling but if gets anywhere close to the Ed Reed comparisons the Jets won't have any complaints.


7. Los Angeles Chargers  - DL Jonathan Allen (Alabama)

I think the Chargers will take either Jamal Adams or Malik Hooker to man a safety spot if they're available at #7. I have both these guys off the board.

Philip Rivers is overdue a WR upgrade and I've had Clemson's Mike Williams mocked to the Chargers for some time. However, there seems to be a fair amount of WR depth this year and the Chargers have not taken a receiver in the 1st round since 2007. So influenced by the depth of draft class and pressing needs at other positions too, I've the Chargers bolstering the D-line with Jonathan Allen who posted 28 sacks during his college career and can probably offer 3-down versatility across the D-line.


8. Carolina Panthers - RB Dalvin Cook (Florida State)

I think the Panthers would benefit enormously from further depth at RB and at #8 should have at least one of the top two prospects here, possibly even a free choice of the two. I've Fournette off the board, leaving Dalvin Cook as the top-rated remaining back. There was a little knock on Cook following the combine agility drills but I think they've been overstated. The last running back from Florida State to be selected in the first round was Warrick Dunn, he subsequently won the offensive rookie of the year award back in 1997. Cook has the potential to follow in these footsteps.

As regards other positional needs, the Panthers could maybe look to add O-line depth or go for a playmaker in the secondary. I think O-line is a tough one to call, it's a strong positional need for Carolina, but success of first round O-line picks in recent years has been variable - it's arguably the highest positional lottery of the draft and is without the stand-out first round candidate in this rookie class. There is some sense in further secondary help in a division with Matt Ryan, Drew Brees and Jameis Winston, but with the top two safeties and corner off the board, I'll stick with a running game weapon to complement Cam Newton.


9. Cincinnati Bengals - WR Mike Williams (Clemson)

The Bengals loss of receivers Jones and Sanu in 2016 free agency was felt the entire season last year. They've took a similar double hit on their O-line during this years free agency with the departures of Andrew Whitworth and Kevin Zeitler. Unless they make some late free agency moves they must be confident that in-house replacements or draftees can protect Andy Dalton and provide WR depth.

The draft class O-line options in the first round would seem limited to Ryan Ramczyk, Garret Bolles or possibly Cam Robinson. I think the Bengals will also entertain the possibility of someone on the D-line in the mould of Taco Charlton or Derek Barnett.

Ultimately, I think the Bengals go for best value at #9 and providing a top class WR2 opposite of A.J Green would bolster the passing attack considerably.


10. Buffalo Bills - QB Deshaun Watson (Clemson)

I've toyed around with the pick in Buffalo and I'm uncertain which direction the Bills are looking. Despite the retention of Tyrod Taylor, his week 17 benching confirmed for me that the organisation aren't entirely sold on him.

The National Championship winning MVP QB Deshaun Watson has his doubters, and I'd probably agree that with his supporting cast at Clemson he should have been more dominant, but he's still been undoubtedly one of the best college QB's the last 2 years.

Watson's leadership skills and ability to play at his best with the game on the line make him an intriguing option to compete in Buffalo. With Taylor retained, Watson can be transitioned into the starting role at his own pace.


11. New Orleans Saints - LB Reuben Foster (Alabama)

The Saints still need defensive help and lack playmakers on that side of the ball. I initially had Reuben Foster mocked to the Saints here at #11 until he was sent home from the combine following an off-field altercation.

I'm not sure whether events at the combine affect Foster's draft
stock or not. I think it maybe has the Saints considering their alternatives and Haason Reddick would be a similar playmaking weapon to integrate into the defense at OLB or off the edge, or maybe one of the pure defensive ends in the draft class.

However, Foster has All Pro potential and it's hard for a struggling Saints defense to ignore this promise at a position of need in New Orleans.


12. Cleveland Browns - TE O.J. Howard (Alabama)

Lots of talk surrounding Cleveland at #12. There's rumours they're entertaining a move back into the top 10 which presumably would be for QB? This #12 could also be the pick used to acquire Jimmy Garoppolo from the Patriots. My mock does not allow for traded picks so the Browns remain here.

Should all the QB's remain on the board and these rumours of trade ups realistic, it would seem to be the reasonable and most likely selection. However, against conventional wisdom and experience of QB's typically being over-drafted I'm predicting a fall of the passers this year and have the Browns taking another "safe pick" - if that's ever possible.

Despite a strong TE class, O.J Howard is the best prospect in terms of versatility as both a blocker and a receiver, has great hands and can stretch the field. It might not be the most pressing positional need but is a vital safety valve for whomever is QB.

If I'm the Browns I'm thinking maybe Patrick Mahomes or Deshone Kizer early in the 2nd round as my passer to compete with Cody Kessler next year.


13. Arizona Cardinals -  DE Taco Charlton (Michigan)

The Cardinals are a tough team to predict. With many of the QB class of 2017 still on the board here I could see them line up an eventual replacement for Carson Palmer. Similarly, it's Larry Fitgerald's
swansong and they could take advantage of giving a 1st round rookie WR a years tutelage by Fitzgerald. Equally the Cards may wish to bolster the secondary or pass-rush, I'm really not sure.

However, with Palmer and Fitzgerald still in Arizona the franchise remains in a win now mode and whilst not a like-for-like replacement, I'm going with the 6'6 edge rusher Taco Charlton to be drafted to attempt to fill the major hole from the departure of Calais Campbell in free agency. My only concern here is that Charlton maybe carries some of the on-field inconsistencies similar to last years 1st rounder Robert Nkemdiche, however the skill set and potential of Charlton cannot be ignored.


14. Philadelphia Eagles - CB Marlon Humphrey (Alabama)

The likely school of thought here is for the Eagles to take a cornerback early in the draft, possibly moreso with the release of Leodis McKelvin and the free agent signings of WR's Alshon Jeffrey and Torrey Smith providing Carson Wentz with further receiving options at what was their other most
pressing positional need.

I think the shake-up from the earlier picks in this round may help determine the selection here but Mike Williams, Corey Davis and John Ross could all be considerations at receiver with Ryan Ramczyk or Garret Bolles options on the O-line. Of the defensive options Marlon Humphrey or Gareon Conley at the corner position or someone like Derek Barnett could be in the mix to upgrade the D-line. The one left-field selection I'd love to see is Christian McCaffrey whose father is ex-Giant WR Ed. It would make a nice editorial piece but also give the Eagles a real game breaking talent to utilise in the backfield and split out wide.

However, against my own personal preference for McCaffrey I'll stick with the popular positional need pick at cornerback and given the recent rumours surrounding Conley will go with the safer option of Alabama's Marlon Humphrey.


15. Indianapolis Colts - OL Ryan Ramczyk (Wisconsin)

This is a big draft for new GM Chris Ballard who has to unpick a roster weakened over recent Ryan Grigson led drafts. The team needs are along both lines and whilst D-line depth is strong in this rookie class I think the Colts will be led by having to keep their franchise guy upright and for me the investment in O-line is critical for Andrew Luck.

The Colts are likely to have their pick of O-linemen in the middle of the 1st round, so it would come to a preference choice between Ryan Ramcyk, Cam Robinson or Garret Bolles.

I think Ramczyk is probably the pick of the three and has the athleticism to cope at left tackle in the NFL. His learning curve won't be as steep as some rookie tackles as he's played in a pro-style system at Wisconsin. The last Badger tackle to be selected in the first round was potential future Hall-of-Famer Joe Thomas. Not a bad guy to follow on from.


16 - Baltimore Ravens - DE/OLB Haason Reddick (Temple)

If the draft falls this way it's probably the ideal scenario for Baltimore. Their most pressing of needs are WR and LB, and both options here at #16 would have top-rated players at these postions still available.

If it were me, I'd hand in the Haason Reddick card pretty damn quickly and look forward to finding some WR depth later in the draft.

Reddick posted some impressive numbers as an edge rusher at Temple (10 sacks in 2016) but allayed concerns over his size and turned even more heads when he was asked to play OLB at the Senior Bowl and looked at home in coverage and when asked to rush the passer.


17 - Washington Redskins - WR John Ross (Washington)

Losing Desean Jackson to free agency may coincidentally be addressed by signing his younger (see also cheaper) clone in John Ross. Ross worked out with Desean pre-draft and provides a similar skill set to D-Jax.

Ross' stock rose notably at the combine when he ran the fastest ever 40, surpassing Chris Johnson's record that had stood since 2008 and dispelling any remaining concerns over his top-end speed following a torn ACL which cost him the whole of his 2015 season.

Ross had already rebounded from the injury with over 1,100 yards receiving in his junior season, complemented with 17 receiving TD's. Declaring early for the draft, he should provide a deep threat weapon here.


18 - Tennessee Titans - WR Corey Davis (Western Michigan)


Having mocked Marshon Lattimore at corner as their first priority at #5 the Titans must surely address WR at #18.

The Titans will be delighted if one of the top 3 receivers in this class still remain on the board at #18 and as chance would have it, I still have Corey Davis available, who many experts rank the #1 WR in the draft class. Davis posted 1,500 receiving yards and 19 TD's in his last season in college and at 6'3 provides a good size target for Marcus Mariota to work with.

I think the WR pick is a no-brainer if it falls into place like this.


19 - Tampa Bay Buccaneers - DE Derek Barnett (Tennessee)

The NFC South is a pass oriented division and edge rushers are at a premium. I'm not sure Derek Barnett really falls this low, but think it a possibility. He might not be the quick twitch edge rusher scouts will rave about but was massively effective in college amassing 33 sacks and his play should effectively translate to the pros.


20 - Denver Broncos - DL Malik McDowell (Michigan St)

The Broncos need some O-line help and I think Garret Bolles or Cam Robinson may be considered or even Forrest Lamp who played tackle in college but may be better suited to the interior in the pros. The Broncos may be tempted by Christian McCaffrey and have the connection to his father Ed. However, I wouldn't be at all surprised to see reinforcements on the D-line via Malik McDowell or an edge guy such as Tak McKinley or Charles Harris. McDowell didn't have a great final year in college and there are questions on effort but there is All Pro potential to unlock under the correct organisation


21 - Detroit Lions - DE/OLB Charles Harris (Missouri)

The Lions are probably looking defense here though could be swayed if one of the top WR's remain. With Mike Williams, John Ross and Corey Davis all off the board I'm thinking that pass-rush is the most likely area to address.

The options here would appear to be between Takkarist McKinley, Tim Williams or Charles Harris. I think Harris is the most likely candidate.


22 - Miami Dolphins - LB Zach Cunningham (Vanderbilt)

This might be a slight reach at #24 but Cunningham was a play-making machine in college and freed up in the Miami defense could replicate his achievements from Vanderbilt down in Florida.


23 - NY Giants - RB Christian McCaffrey (Stanford)

It's probably too convenient that I have the Giants taking Stanford's Christian McCaffrey and allowing him to follow in his father
Ed's footsteps some 26 years after he was drafted by the Giants (Ed McCaffrey was selected in 3rd round #83 in 1991).

McCaffrey's a multi-dimensional runner with the skills of a receiver in the passing game, notably being asked to run routes with the wide receivers at the combine.

He posted eye-popping numbers in 2015 leading Stanford in both rushing and receiving (the only FBS player to do so) and his so-called down year still amassed 1,639 yards in 2016. He might not be a 20 carries per game back, but he's certainly a 20 touches per game back.


24 - Oakland Raiders - DL Takkarist McKinley (UCLA)

Probably the rawest prospect to go in the 1st round this year, McKinley has the potential to dominate if he can be taught pass-rush technique. He's a relentless competitor who got better each year at UCLA and saw his sack totals increase year-on-year up to his final year where he posted double digit sacks.


25 - Houston Texans - QB Mitchell Trubisky (North Carolina)

I'm resisting the option of the Texans pairing up T.J Watt to team with his more famous brother.

Surely the Texans don't see Tom Savage as their QB of the future? Houston aren't that far away from a Superbowl team but the QB position has held them back during the entire Bill O'Brien era.

Trubisky comes with a number of question marks having spent 98% of his time in college operating a spread offense from shotgun. He'll have a steep learning curve reading defenses from under Center, learning to throw within a tighter window etc but has good mobility and a strong arm that can make all the throws. He's not the finished article by any means but has been given some favourable comparisons to Carson Wentz from last years draft class. I can't see the Texans letting him get past #25 if indeed he gets this far.


26 - Seattle Seahawks - OT Garret Bolles (Utah)

There's some talk of Obi Melifonwu here - a 6'4 224lbs imposing safety who impressed at the combine. He doesn't look as good on gameday though so may be a bit of a project to take this early. Instead I believe the Seahawks will look to improve their O-line to give Russell Wilson better protection. The most likely selection would be the athletic Garret Bolles or possibly Cam Robinson. Either would provide much needed competition on the O-line.


27 - KC Chiefs - LB/S Jabrill Peppers (Michigan)

Peppers is a bit of a wildcard in this class, labelled a swiss-army knife in his college career who contributed on offense, special teams and defense during his time at Michigan. He models himself as a Charles Woodson style hybrid safety/linebacker, even choosing Michigan for that very reason so would probably love to go to Oakland or Green Bay but let's make no bones, he's nowhere near Woodson's level....yet.

Some experts feel his game has suffered due to his versatility and believe he'll prosper given a fixed position in the NFL. In KC, he'd be learning off one of the best in Eric Berry.


28 - Dallas Cowboys - TE David Njoku (Miami)

Njoku is the next in a long line of Miami tight ends to hit the pro's (Greg Olson, Jimmy Graham, Jeremy Shockey et al). He would be an intriguing pick for Dallas bringing plus athleticism and speed for the position and will cause several mismatch issues for defenses. He's not the finished article and his blocking needs lots of work, but Dallas would be an ideal fit for Njoku as he learns his trade from Jason Witten.


29 - Green Bay Packers - LB T.J Watt (Wisconsin)

I'd love to see McCaffrey here if not in Philly, but think him long gone by #29. I'm expecting the Packers to address the defense in the 1st round but wonder whether Ty Montgomery can really carry the load for a full season in Green Bay. It's possible that Lambeau could be a safe haven for Joe Mixon or Alvin Kamara but I
think the 1st round may be too high for either of these backs and their off-field baggage.

I think the Packers look to defensive line or secondary and possibly entertain T.J Watt as their pick. The brother of J.J may not be quite the same impact player and does come with some injury history, but when he was finally injury free last year he posted an impressive 63 tackles and 11.5 sacks. Teaming Watt up with Clay Matthews could be an intriguing prospect.


30 - Pittsburgh Steelers - S Budda Baker (Washington)



I think the Steelers are looking to address the D-line and secondary as main priorities in the first round and will surely add a WR at some point with on-going off-field issues surrounding Martavis Bryant.

I think Budda Baker could be an intriguing selection here - an undersized Safety with excellent ball skills and a linebacker mentality - does that remind anyone of Steeler legend Troy Polamalu? Just saying....



31 - Atlanta Falcons - OG Forrest Lamp (Western Kentucky)

I don't think Atlanta have many pressing needs on offense but the one glaring hole is at right guard following the retirement of Chris Chester. Aside from this position I don't think they'll consider much on offense with the exception of TE possibly in the later rounds. I fully expect the majority of other picks to be spent across the defensive line, linebacker and free safety.

For the first round I think it's a choice of edge rusher or guard. I suspect the ideal scenario is a pass-rusher with options at Guard in Rd2 or Rd3, but if Lamp is on the board at #31 it should be a no-brainer. Lamp played tackle for Western Kentucky but is an ideal fit to move inside in the NFL. He's athletic and should fit the zone block concepts nicely in Atlanta.

And yes, I'm not afraid to admit that I did spend his 40 run at the combine shouting 'Run Forrest Run'


32 - New Orleans Saints - CB Teez Tabor (Florida)

The Saints second pick of the round courtesy of the Brandin Cooks trade, I suspect it's another pick on the defensive side of the ball. There are plenty of corners carrying a low round 1 / high round 2 grade and I'm not sure where they go. On paper Sidney Jones is probably the best corner but tore his achilles on his pro day. Gareon Conley carried a 1st round grade but an accusation of rape in the lead-up to the draft probably hits his stock. I think this leaves the Saints gambling or dropping down a level to the likes of Teez Tabor, Adoree Jackson, Tre'davious White, Quincy Jones and others.